Think back to the last time you bought a home
or a car and you can quickly recall the mind-boggling amount of fine print and
fee disclosures you waded through and agreed to. Well, when it comes to
investments, there are fees too – that’s how those who research and manage the
investment are compensated and an integral part of why and how the opportunity
is available to you.
Knowing that there are fees associated with
any big transaction is one thing, but understanding what they’re for and how
they affect you and your investment partners is another. Having the fees in a
commercial real estate syndication decoded alters the dynamic from feeling like
the fees or those responsible for them are “out to get you,” and rather that
they are important to the success of all involved.
In this article I’ll walk you through the most
common fees typically seen in a commercial real estate syndication and,
together, we can walk through what each one means and what passive investors
should watch out for when examining an investment opportunity.
Deflating Investors’ Myths Around
Real Estate Syndication Deals
As with any misunderstanding, therein lies
some false beliefs and assumptions. So, let’s take it from the top in our
comprehensive fee explanation journey, and debunk the top myths investors
believe when it comes to real estate syndications.
Myth #1 – Investors Have No
Control
You may believe that when you invest in a
commercial real estate syndication, all control over your capital is
relinquished. This is far from the truth because, while you may not be
selecting paint colors or problem-solving for trash pick up, you have 100% say
in what type of asset you invest, the asset class, the capital amount, which
deal with which sponsor, whether you choose a value-add deal or not, and so
much more.
When you invest in a syndication, your control
is exerted up front, during the selection and research process so that once
you’ve selected a deal and wired your funds, you can use the precious time you
have to do what you want with those you love.
Myth #2 – Investors Earn Lower
Returns
Maybe you’ve heard a rumor that syndications
yield lower returns, but this is confusing because real estate historically
outperforms the stock market. No matter what type of investment you’re exploring,
make sure you’re comparing “apples to apples.”
Many investors (even experienced ones!) can
make the mistake of comparing gross returns to net returns. Since gross returns
are the profits or earnings before any fees are taken out while net returns are
reflective of what you’ll actually take home, this could be quite misleading.
When exploring and comparing commercial real
estate syndication deals, yes, there are always fees, but there are 3 things to
consider as you sort through them:
1)
Are the fees creating alignment
between the investment and asset goals of the general and limited partners and
driving performance?
2)
Can you still make a reasonable
(projected) return on your capital that propels you toward your goals?
3)
Are the sponsors being transparent
about the fees being charged and what they’re for?
No one likes hidden or surprise fees, so when
the general partnership is being transparent, the fees listed are reasonable,
and you still make money, that’s a win!
If you’re like me, you don’t have the time or
mental energy for fee gymnastics. Instead, ensure that your investment choice
is based on the projected net returns across the board. That is, you want to be
comparing investment opportunities’ returns after fees have already been
removed so you have clarity on how that passive income might affect your budget
and your goals.
The Most Common Fees In A Real
Estate Syndication Investment
To further deflate myth #2, it’s imperative to
understand why the fees on a deal exist and their purpose. With that knowledge,
you can more deeply understand how a real estate syndication works and more
confidently peruse through the business plan, PPM (private placement
memorandum), and decide definitively if a deal aligns with your goals or not.
Ready to learn about each type of fee? Don’t
worry, it’s not that complicated.
Acquisition
Fee – This is typically 1-3% of the purchase price of
the asset and covers costs associated with the resources and due diligence
performed by the sponsor to acquire the asset.
Sometimes sponsors spend weeks or even months
researching and underwriting deal after deal to no avail. The acquisition fee
is what keeps the lights on, so to speak, and helps afford all that effort
during and between deals.
Asset
Management Fee – At about 1-2% of either the projected
gross income or the capital invested (sponsor’s preference), this money pays
for the ongoing bookkeeping, coordination, and communication that’s required to
properly manage the asset and execute on the business plan.
Construction
Management Fee – On value-add or development deals, a
construction management fee of about 5-10% of the expected construction budget
is necessary for managing the renovations on the property. Attentive, thorough
oversight is required to ensure construction projects finish on time and within
budget.
Equity
Placement Fee – A fee charged upfront by the broker
that covers the cost of obtaining investors, limited partners (like you!) and
the marketing, coordination, and behind-the-scenes communication and paperwork.
Also sometimes called the equity origination fee, this is usually around 1-2%
of the capital invested.
Loan
Fee – This fee compensates the sponsor for their work
toward obtaining financing because getting a loan of this size takes immense
effort. A loan fee is typically 1% of the total loan amount.
Guarantor
Fee – Occasionally, loans require a key partner to
personally pledge assets to guarantee the loan. Typically between 1-2% of the
loan amount compensates the guarantor for their pledge and support.
Refinance
Fee – At about 1-2% of the refinanced loan amount,
this fee, also called a capital event, compensates key parties for the time and
energy it takes to refinance the property. If you’ve ever received a portion of
your investment capital back and experienced the joy of cash-on-cash returns as
if all your capital was still invested, you’ll probably agree that the
refinance fee is well worth it!
Disposition
Fee – Finally, a disposition fee is often charged to
cover the costs of marketing and selling the asset once the business plan has
been executed. 1-2% of the sales price of the asset ensures a smooth transition
from your syndication ownership to the next party.
How To Become A Fee-Savvy Passive
Investor
With a deep understanding of the possible fees
on a deal – what they’re for and how much they may be – keep in mind that each
sponsor may present varying fees (in number and by percentage) depending upon
their values.
Here at Elemental
Equity, one of our guiding values is transparency. So when we publish a
proforma, the projected returns are net of fees. It’s important to us that
documents are easy for our investors to understand and evaluate.
Typically the cash-on-cash returns (quarterly
disbursements) and IRR projections are net of the acquisition fee, asset
management fee, disposition fee, and, if applicable, a refinance and/or
guarantor fee. In general, people don’t like fees, so the fewer the better! That’s
why you typically won’t see more than about 4 fees on our commercial real
estate syndication deals.
As part of your journey in getting started as
a passive investor, learning about and understanding the fee structure is one
more checkbox checked toward being ready to grab a seat in our next deal. If
you haven’t already, make sure you join the Elemental Investor
Club today so you can begin browsing opportunities!